Reviewer Guidelines

1. Initial Review

Scope & Relevance
• Confirm that the manuscript fits within JIEBP’s aims and scope Islamic economics, Islamic finance, Islamic business management, and related contemporary issues.
Abstract Screening
• Read the abstract to ensure the topic matches your expertise. If it does not, notify the editor immediately.
Research Question
• Evaluate whether the study is significant, original, and contributes meaningfully to the field of Islamic economics and business.
Methodology (for research papers)
• Assess whether the research design, data collection, and analysis methods are appropriate and rigorous, or if there are critical flaws.
Initial Impression
• Decide whether the paper is:

2. Full Review

Scientific Quality
• Are the objectives clear and the results substantial?
• Are arguments logical, well-structured, and supported by sound reasoning and evidence?
• Are interpretations consistent with the data presented?
Writing & Presentation
• Is the manuscript logically organized and easy to follow?
• Are terminology and abbreviations used correctly?
• Is grammar, punctuation, and spelling at an acceptable level? Provide examples if language issues are systemic, but do not attempt full editing.
Style & Format
• Does the manuscript follow JIEBP’s style, formatting, and referencing requirements (APA 7th edition)?
• Are all citations accurate and properly documented?

3. Reviewer Ethics

Treat all manuscripts and related communication as strictly confidential.
Decline the review if you have any conflict of interest (financial, institutional, or personal).
Provide objective, evidence-based, and constructive feedback to help authors improve their work.
Avoid personal criticism of the authors.

4. Recommendation

Select one of the following recommendations when submitting your review: